Claudia Banton sentenced to 23 years-to-life for shooting childhood friend execution-style in Crown Heights

Inside the courtroom, Johnson’s mother, Delia Berry, delivered a powerful victim impact statement, locking eyes with Banton — a woman she once considered like her daughter.

Shakti Denis

May 19, 2025, 10:40 PM

Updated 4 hr ago

Share:

Applause broke out in a Brooklyn courtroom Monday, as Claudia Banton was sentenced to 23 years-to-life in prison for the 2021 execution-style killing of Delia Johnson.
The sentencing marked the end of a four-year ordeal for Johnson’s family.
“I feel like she deserved more,” said Johnson’s sister, Cordelia McCray. “But today is about change, and today is about forgiving.”
Johnson, 42, was shot in the head on a Crown Heights sidewalk in August 2021. The killing was caught on surveillance video, shocking the community and sending police on a months-long manhunt. Banton, 46, was arrested in Florida nearly four months later.
Inside the courtroom, Johnson’s mother, Delia Berry, delivered a powerful victim impact statement, locking eyes with Banton — a woman she once considered like her daughter.
“I did the best that I could for Claudia,” Berry said.
Tears rolled down Banton’s cheeks as Johnson’s relatives described the deep pain of losing a sister, mother, and friend.
“Her kids can still call her, still visit her,” said Johnson’s brother, Mathis Lemons. “I’ll never see my sister again. I’ll never laugh with her again.”
Johnson’s 21-year-old daughter, currently deployed with the U.S. Air Force, appeared via video in uniform. Struggling to put her pain into words, she thanked Banton for at least ensuring her mother “didn’t suffer.”
Banton did not address the family for legal reason, according to her attorney, Jonathan Strauss, adding that her silence should not be mistaken for indifference.
Strauss said they’re planning to appeal the decision, citing a surprise witness mid-trial.
“There’s a lot of legal issues that need to be addressed in the appeal,” said Strauss.
Judge Margaret Martin grew emotional as she handed down the sentence, acknowledging the profound grief Johnson’s family continues to carry.
“And it ain't easy,” said McCray. “But I know one day it will get better.”